iPhone 4 Indoor Video Test

http://twitter.com/ChrisPirillo ~ http://www.facebook.com/chrispirillo ~ http://youtube.com/ChrisPirillo

The reason I chose to shoot indoors (with and without artificial light) was to better illustrate “extreme” conditions – knowing that people shoot video “inside” all the time with little regard for light sources.

– iPhone 4 Version: http://youtu.be/2GB8YYe0UCU

– Original iPhone Video: http://blip.tv/file/get/L0ckergn0me-iPhone4IndoorVideoTest527.MOV

– HTC Evo 4G Version: http://youtu.be/waq8jMLT2Ro

– Original HTC Evo 4G Video: http://blip.tv/file/get/L0ckergn0me-HTCEvo4GIndoorVideoTest155.3gp

Notes:

* I didn’t edit the raw footage for a reason; compare sources for yourself.
* The Evo seems to have a wider field of view compared to the iPhone.
* The iPhone audio sampling rate is 44k (64Kbps) vs 8k (12.8Kbps) on the Evo.
* Sunshine through my red curtains was difficult for each camera to handle.
* The Evo lens seems to tint blue or red at times.
* Frame rates were diminished on each device: 24fps (iPhone) vs 11fps (Evo).
* The Evo produces an MPEG-4 “3GP” file vs an MPEG-4 “MOV” file from the iPhone.
* The default Evo camera app is superior in features, but lackluster in performance.
* Research indicates the Evo upscales 320p to 720p, FWIW.

Clearly, the Evo (with default settings) doesn’t hold a candle to the iPhone 4 (with default settings). I’m sure other camera apps would force the device(s) to record differently, but this test was designed to compare phone defaults.

While the iPhone isn’t perfect, I’d certainly consider it a Flip, Kodak Zi*, and Vado killer.

You are more than welcome to upload your own tests as video responses to this.

Duration : 0:2:2


[youtube 2GB8YYe0UCU]

25 Responses to “iPhone 4 Indoor Video Test”

  1. fucken geek!
    fucken geek!

  2. And I do have to …
    And I do have to agree that the iPhone camera is better than the Evo, thats if this is an honest test. Not saying its not…. just saying so don’t get excited and rage you fanfags.

  3. To me their just …
    To me their just phones. But considering that the Sprints plan is way cheaper than AT&Ts plan is a big plus. Now I am leaning more towards the Evo because well, There is most likely less if anything at all to go wrong with the phone. Just look at the iPhones antenna problem and Apples response to it is you’re holding it the wrong way? Now Apple is reinventing the way we hold phones to. Well just my 2 cents on both phones. Treat them equally. Feel free to respond, only logical responses apply.

  4. Wow. I’m very into …
    Wow. I’m very into photography, and I’m glad I’m buying my iPhone 4 today.

  5. aMPLiFYProductions on July 14th, 2010 at 5:42 pm

    @035577 a Fandroid …
    @035577 a Fandroid actually means Fan of androids and i just shortened it by naming them Fandroids, is that a good enough explanation?

  6. @aMPLiFYProductions …
    @aMPLiFYProductions the is a fandroid? is that supposed to be clever??

  7. Good Job. Thanks …
    Good Job. Thanks for posting!

  8. The audio and video …
    The audio and video are both far clearer here than on the EVO 4G. The difference in audio clarity is unbelievable to me.

  9. this guy has no …
    this guy has no life lol

  10. aMPLiFYProductions on July 14th, 2010 at 5:42 pm

    looks like theres …
    looks like theres 29 fandroids disliked this video :D

  11. @tannerstouch lol i …
    @tannerstouch lol i think your replying to the wrong person mate ;)

  12. LOL i like how the …
    LOL i like how the iphone’s 360p looks better than the EVO 720HD wow. fail?

  13. @jebussaves1 enough …
    @jebussaves1 enough for your personal douchebag to fit though

  14. Gnome, you do any …
    Gnome, you do any test with both phones at their “highest” quality settings? Because even though it would be nice to use a phone’s default settings, I rather judge the camera’s at their best settings. Thanks.

  15. As much as I’m …
    As much as I’m leaning towards the Evo, from what I’ve seen, the iPhone’s camera absolutely destroys the Evo’s camera.

  16. @speedyduck38 he …
    @speedyduck38 he lives on his own you idiot he pays for his stuff..

  17. iphone 4 raped lol
    iphone 4 raped lol

  18. u have a nice room …
    u have a nice room bro. wish i was tht spoiled lol

  19. wow the iphone …
    wow the iphone owned :O

  20. Get ready youtube …
    Get ready youtube you will be spammed by loads of user created high def crap

  21. people seem to …
    people seem to forget Apple invented the iPhone, or the new standard interface/mobileOS for their own category of “smartphone”… so they refine their creation, they don’t waste time trying to make it bigger like the competition.

    I think it’s amazing that they’ve made its even smaller, with higher rez screen, more features and higher quality components… by their standards of design, not conceding to the one upmanship of the clones. If you want a larger iPhone get the iPad and use Skype.

  22. sick quality
    sick quality

  23. if HTC came out …
    if HTC came out with a phone just 3 months earlier that had the iphone 4’s camera and display, i’d say “good job. you finally cracked the iphone” and i’d probably buy it. but this phone hardly stands up to the 3gs!!!

  24. the real funny …
    the real funny thing is, you cant even view the HD videos you just recorded with your evo in its native resolution on the evo’s screen. even the retina display blows everything else out of the water. the evo is still trying to compete with the 3gs (and by these test i’d still want my 3gs camera)

  25. iwouldlikesometea on July 14th, 2010 at 5:42 pm

    I get the iphone 4 …
    I get the iphone 4 for free.

Leave a Reply